The Ongoing Debate Between PvE and PvP

Since the launch of Arc Raiders, the player base has been deeply divided regarding the game's direction. While many enjoy the cooperative experience of fighting off machines, a significant portion of the community craves the intensity of player-versus-player combat. Developer Embark Studios has previously indicated a desire to keep the title as a more accessible extraction shooter, with CEO Patrick Söderlund noting that the core philosophy isn't necessarily centered on player-on-player conflict.

Despite these design goals, the community's demand for aggressive gameplay hasn't waned, leading to a clash between those who want to hunt machines and those who want to hunt other players for their resources.


The 'Rival Gangs' Proposal

A Reddit user going by the handle Forward_Problem_7550 has introduced a compelling solution to address the lack of dedicated combat focus: a proposed game mode titled 'Rival Gangs'. Expressing clear frustration with the constant emphasis on PvE, the user argues that the developers need to cater to the PvP-centric portion of their audience.

The proposed mode introduces specific mechanics to ensure high-stakes gameplay:

  • High-Difficulty Modifiers: Maps would be significantly more dangerous but offer superior loot rewards.
  • Limited Extraction: Fewer return points and hatches would make escaping with loot much harder.
  • Entry Requirements: To participate, players would be required to bring equipment valued at a minimum of 30,000 raider coins.

The creator of the concept notes, «Hostiles have been spotted in the area. Only well-equipped Raiders are getting clearance to head Topside.»


Could This Concept Work?

The idea of implementing PvP as a specific map modifier is gaining traction within the community. By segregating this activity, players could engage in chaotic combat without negatively impacting the experience for those who prefer a PvE-focused matchmaking environment. Furthermore, the mandatory loadout value provides a strong incentive for conflict, as it ensures that every participant has a meaningful investment at risk.

While the 'Rival Gangs' mode remains a fan-made concept, it mirrors mechanics seen in other titles, such as the upcoming Marathon, which has explored similar gear-value requirements for its ranked modes. Whether Embark Studios will ever adopt such a feature remains to be seen, but it highlights a clear desire among the player base for more challenging, combat-oriented endgame content.